• 2 Posts
  • 21 Comments
Joined 4 months ago
cake
Cake day: April 27th, 2024

help-circle




















  • My opinion is that Jesse Lyu is lying about making any significant changes. (Because otherwise the demo wouldn’t have worked)

    I don’t want bad things for him personally, but I want bad things to happen to people who lie in public.

    The code is open source with licensing requirements, so I’m therefore hoping someone Jesse has already made a statement to can write him with these requests:

    • For GPL2 licensed components such as Linux: Give me your changes in source form.
    • For Apache-licensed components such as Android: What files did you change?

    I can imagine him responding in three ways:

    • “Sure, here is another lie” – and then he’s locked into an answer which will probably make him look clueless as hell
    • “We don’t think we have to do that” – and now the Open Source Reply Guy Brigade instantly hates him.
    • <no reply> – and now, given that a conversation has actually occurred, he looks evasive.

  • I read a few of the guy’s other blog posts and they follow a general theme:

    • He’s pretty resourceful! Surprisingly often, when he’s feeling comfortable, he resorts to sensible troubleshooting steps.
    • Despite that, when confronted with code, it seems like he often just kind of guesses at what things mean without verifying it.
    • When he’s decided he doesn’t understand a thing, he WILL NOT DIG INTO THE THING.

    He seems totally hireable as a junior, but he absolutely needs the adult supervision.

    The LLM Revolution seems really really bad for this guy specifically – it promises that he can keep working in this ineffective way without changing anything.