Khalil al-Hayya, a deputy to Hamas Gaza leader Yahya Sinwar says the group's aim is not to run Gaza but to shake the Middle East and put Palestinian issue back in focus; Tells New York Times expected Arab world to join fight
How often does a democracy have elections? Pretty sure it’s more than once a generation. It helps your agenda to pretend Hamas and Palestine are synonyms, but that doesn’t make it true.
How often does Russia have legitimate elections? Never. The Putin administration is still the government of Russia, just as Hamas is the government of Palestine in Gaza.
So then your stance is in direct opposition to history that Hamas is completely unrelated to Palestine? Do you know the history of Hamas? Which government did it form under? Which people elected it in 2006?
What happens after that election doesn’t make much of a difference to me. Those very same people could still be happy with Hamas (I don’t see a civil war kicking them out…)
Either Hamas is unpopular or it’s popular. Either way you’ve now argued for both. And yet you tell me I’m falling for propaganda. Your own talking parts aren’t even consistent.
A: time exists. As the occupation as become more brutal and unjust, the more a reactionary militant force is going to gain popularity. I fucking hate the cops, but I’m going to call them in extreme distress for example.
B: even if they were unpopular, you have to be a special level of hated before you’re expelled and ‘civil warred’
Kicked out of power vs kicked out of the country is far far different. You seem to assume that I meant the latter.
If I’m not happy with a government… and have no way to vote in a different one, popularity would plummet… eventually Gaza population should desire to kick Hamas out of power no? How come Fatah or other factions can’t come in and take over? The only answer is that in Gaza, Hamas has sufficient popularity…
You understand a large portion of the population wasn’t born at the time of that election, right?
Considering that we’re talking about 2006… only 17 years ago… Only people we consider children would not have been born yet (and generally aren’t allowed to vote). So this is moot point.
You understand that election was forced by the US, right?
Evidence please. You’ve just made a claim that it not immediately supported by anything. US has had involvement with Israel… Not Palestine. The 2006 elections were entirely Palestinian controlled as far as I can see.
You understand the US failed to coup Hamas and solidified their power, right?
Once again. We tend to back Israel… Not Palestine. Which would have put us attempting to help Israel AGAINST Hamas…
You think little babies should be blown to bits over an election 17 years ago right?
Oh shit… you can do math! If you read the article that this Lemmy thread is about… you’d see that THEY CHOSE THIS. Blame Hamas. Not US or Israel. they made this choice knowing what would happen. You would think that if they’re so against Hamas, they would have kicked Hamas out long ago.
Maybe 20% of the current population voted for Hamas 17 years ago. Democratic legitimacy has to have some kind of shelf life, no?
Are they still collectively responsible when it’s 10%? Are 2.4 million people responsible when there’s just one remaining person alive who voted for them?
Might want to keep reading past the first few lines there. Israel bombed the shit out of Gaza after that and kidnapped all the moderate, pro Israel members of the Hamas government. Surprise! The people that replaced them were not moderate. There have been no elections since.
Also, Hamas was behind by ten points in polls right before the election, then won by ten points. But yeah, by all means, keep bombing them babies, they deserve it!
After the kidnap of Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit on 25 June 2006, Israel launched a series of raids into Gaza and the West Bank. Israel destroyed civilian infrastructure and arrested dozens of Hamas supporters, including elected cabinet ministers and members of the PLC. On 28 June overnight, the army invaded Gaza and performed airstrikes, bombing infrastructure such as bridges and an electricity station. On 29 June, the IDF detained from the West Bank 8 ministers and 26 PLC members in addition to many other political leaders.[19][41] By August 2006, Israel had arrested 49 senior Hamas officials, all from the West Bank, including 33 parliamentarians, “because technically they were members of a terrorist organisation although they may not be involved in terrorist acts themselves”. Most of the Hamas detainees were moderate members from the West Bank who had been calling on the Gaza leadership to recognise Israel and make the party more acceptable to the international community. Hamas has accused Israel of trying to destroy the Hamas-led Palestinian Authority.[42]
The apologists here keep trying to act like Hamas isn’t literally the government of Palestine in Gaza. It’s as crazy as saying Russia did not invade Ukraine, only the Putin administration invaded Ukraine.
You know Putin came to power through extremely questionable circumstances in 2001 and the “re-elections” have only gotten worse over the last 22 years, ya? But sure, blame civilians because the government pretends to be democratic.
It would not be right to confine and then bomb Russians either.
I get that it’s kind of a third party in the state at this point… But Hamas clearly stems from Palestine no matter what way you look at it. And Palestine still claims control over Gaza… So there’s no functional way to argue anything otherwise without outright lying. It’s of Palestinian origin… was put in place by Palestine… The fact that it might have shifted away from strictly Fatah-based Palestinian control doesn’t change anything. The worst part is… it seems that the Hamas “takeover” was a proper election. So it’s solely on Palestines hands that Hamas exists as far as I can tell.
What I hope people don’t do is assume that I’m condone all of Israel’s actions… since you know… I haven’t brought that up at all. I’m willing to bet all the downvotes are literally those people.
The Hamas party ran on a moderate platform, Israel came in and murdered almost all of the elected leaders six months after they took office. The people who replaced them were not elected and did not have moderate values. They also decided not to have elections anymore. Half of the people who were alive for that election are dead. I don’t feel comfortable with this whole “Well, they’ve made their bed and now they can sleep in it while Israel indiscriminately bombs it” mentality.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Governance_of_the_Gaza_Strip
I’m sorry what?
How often does a democracy have elections? Pretty sure it’s more than once a generation. It helps your agenda to pretend Hamas and Palestine are synonyms, but that doesn’t make it true.
How often does Russia have legitimate elections? Never. The Putin administration is still the government of Russia, just as Hamas is the government of Palestine in Gaza.
So then your stance is in direct opposition to history that Hamas is completely unrelated to Palestine? Do you know the history of Hamas? Which government did it form under? Which people elected it in 2006?
What happens after that election doesn’t make much of a difference to me. Those very same people could still be happy with Hamas (I don’t see a civil war kicking them out…)
Well no… Most of the people that voted for it are dead… Median age in Palestine is 18 or 19
They recognize their actual enemy. Why would they kick out the people attempting to stick up for them?
So one minute…
source:https://lemmings.world/comment/3456084
then the next minute…
source:https://lemmings.world/comment/3458582
Either Hamas is unpopular or it’s popular. Either way you’ve now argued for both. And yet you tell me I’m falling for propaganda. Your own talking parts aren’t even consistent.
A: time exists. As the occupation as become more brutal and unjust, the more a reactionary militant force is going to gain popularity. I fucking hate the cops, but I’m going to call them in extreme distress for example.
B: even if they were unpopular, you have to be a special level of hated before you’re expelled and ‘civil warred’
Stop having a binary child brain please.
When your statement make logical and consistent sense… I’ll give a shit about your ad hominem.
You said “never”. That includes different time periods definitionally.
You’re also assuming I said they are popular when I’m explaining why they haven’t been kicked out
Kicked out of power vs kicked out of the country is far far different. You seem to assume that I meant the latter.
If I’m not happy with a government… and have no way to vote in a different one, popularity would plummet… eventually Gaza population should desire to kick Hamas out of power no? How come Fatah or other factions can’t come in and take over? The only answer is that in Gaza, Hamas has sufficient popularity…
deleted by creator
If the civilian population was responsible for government actions, the United States should have been nuked decades ago.
You understand what elections are right?
You understand a large portion of the population wasn’t born at the time of that election, right?
You understand that election was forced by the US, right?
You understand the US failed to coup Hamas and solidified their power, right?
You think little babies should be blown to bits over an election 17 years ago right?
Considering that we’re talking about 2006… only 17 years ago… Only people we consider children would not have been born yet (and generally aren’t allowed to vote). So this is moot point.
Evidence please. You’ve just made a claim that it not immediately supported by anything. US has had involvement with Israel… Not Palestine. The 2006 elections were entirely Palestinian controlled as far as I can see.
Once again. We tend to back Israel… Not Palestine. Which would have put us attempting to help Israel AGAINST Hamas…
Oh shit… you can do math! If you read the article that this Lemmy thread is about… you’d see that THEY CHOSE THIS. Blame Hamas. Not US or Israel. they made this choice knowing what would happen. You would think that if they’re so against Hamas, they would have kicked Hamas out long ago.
~50% of Gaza is under 18.
Think it through bud, you can do it.
(also I love how if I don’t cite sources on everything I’m automatically wrong because it doesn’t confirm to the propoganda you’ve been fed lmao)
Maybe 20% of the current population voted for Hamas 17 years ago. Democratic legitimacy has to have some kind of shelf life, no?
Are they still collectively responsible when it’s 10%? Are 2.4 million people responsible when there’s just one remaining person alive who voted for them?
Might want to keep reading past the first few lines there. Israel bombed the shit out of Gaza after that and kidnapped all the moderate, pro Israel members of the Hamas government. Surprise! The people that replaced them were not moderate. There have been no elections since.
Also, Hamas was behind by ten points in polls right before the election, then won by ten points. But yeah, by all means, keep bombing them babies, they deserve it!
The apologists here keep trying to act like Hamas isn’t literally the government of Palestine in Gaza. It’s as crazy as saying Russia did not invade Ukraine, only the Putin administration invaded Ukraine.
You know Putin came to power through extremely questionable circumstances in 2001 and the “re-elections” have only gotten worse over the last 22 years, ya? But sure, blame civilians because the government pretends to be democratic.
It would not be right to confine and then bomb Russians either.
I get that it’s kind of a third party in the state at this point… But Hamas clearly stems from Palestine no matter what way you look at it. And Palestine still claims control over Gaza… So there’s no functional way to argue anything otherwise without outright lying. It’s of Palestinian origin… was put in place by Palestine… The fact that it might have shifted away from strictly Fatah-based Palestinian control doesn’t change anything. The worst part is… it seems that the Hamas “takeover” was a proper election. So it’s solely on Palestines hands that Hamas exists as far as I can tell.
What I hope people don’t do is assume that I’m condone all of Israel’s actions… since you know… I haven’t brought that up at all. I’m willing to bet all the downvotes are literally those people.
The Hamas party ran on a moderate platform, Israel came in and murdered almost all of the elected leaders six months after they took office. The people who replaced them were not elected and did not have moderate values. They also decided not to have elections anymore. Half of the people who were alive for that election are dead. I don’t feel comfortable with this whole “Well, they’ve made their bed and now they can sleep in it while Israel indiscriminately bombs it” mentality.